Re: posting hand histories from online sites

[accountant]

Now that I've read the article, I must say that Cooke makes a very good
point - a problem with much of the advice on internet forums is that it's
inaccurate. He offers some names of individuals that are reliable at
United Poker Forum. I don't see anything wrong with that. I read RGP
daily and offer this opinion of the article.

Good job Cooke.



On Apr 18 2003 5:01PM, Bad Bob the Albino wrote:

> On 18 Apr 2003 21:24:34 -0700, tnpokerpro@hotmail.com (TNPokerPro)
> wrote:
>
> >Is it ok to post hand histories from some of the more established
> >online sites? I wanted to post some hands and get some opinions on my
> >play.
> >
> >What I don't want is to get banned from any of the sites for posting
> >actual hand histories.
> >
> >Is it ok???
>
> We got people at RGP that just thrive on hand histories. It is common
> pratice to edit the sensitive info to protect the guilty....
>
> post away....
>
> Bad Bob

_________________________________________________________________
Posted using RecPoker.com - http://www.recpoker.com

[Gary Carson]

I'ts a puff peice for a website he's got a part of. Its an example of
why he's wrong, a moderated commercial site is a less reliable source
of information than an unmoderated site. It's true that you'll see
more bad advice on an unmoderated site, but on an unmoderated site the
bad will always get correctected.

This is the same guy that used planet poker's internal hand histories
to help a buddy improve his game. I'll bet you won't see much
dicusttion of the ethics of that on his website.


On 22 Aug 2003 08:34:43 GMT, "accountant" <anonymous@yahoo.com> wrote:

>Now that I've read the article, I must say that Cooke makes a very
good
>point - a problem with much of the advice on internet forums is that
it's
>inaccurate. He offers some names of individuals that are reliable at
>United Poker Forum. I don't see anything wrong with that. I read
RGP
>daily and offer this opinion of the article.
>
>Good job Cooke.
>
>
>
>On Apr 18 2003 5:01PM, Bad Bob the Albino wrote:
>
>> On 18 Apr 2003 21:24:34 -0700, tnpokerpro@hotmail.com (TNPokerPro)
>> wrote:
>>
>> >Is it ok to post hand histories from some of the more established
>> >online sites? I wanted to post some hands and get some opinions
on my
>> >play.
>> >
>> >What I don't want is to get banned from any of the sites for
posting
>> >actual hand histories.
>> >
>> >Is it ok???
>>
>> We got people at RGP that just thrive on hand histories. It is
common
>> pratice to edit the sensitive info to protect the guilty....
>>
>> post away....
>>
>> Bad Bob
>
>_________________________________________________________________
>Posted using RecPoker.com - http://www.recpoker.com
>
>